Kearl oilsands leak exposes gaps in how Alberta and Canada oversee industry: experts

By Bob Weber, The Canadian Press

EDMONTON — Recent leaks of toxic tailings from northern Alberta oilsands mines have revealed serious flaws in how Canada and Alberta look after the environment, observers say. 

Some accuse the federal government of abandoning the province. Others point to what they call a captive provincial regulator. All agree that there’s no way a leak from Imperial Oil’s Kearl tailings ponds should have gone unreported for nine months to both Ottawa and Edmonton, as well as the people who live near it.

“We have never taken this issue seriously,” said Martin Olszynski, a University of Calgary resource law professor and former federal regulatory lawyer. “They have never taken these risks and these threats seriously.”

Imperial discovered “brown sludge” near one of its Kearl tailings ponds in May and it became clear over the summer the problem was significant.

However, the Alberta Energy Regulator didn’t update First Nations or inform federal and provincial environment ministers about the issue until Feb. 7, when it issued a protection order after a second Kearl release of 5.3 million litres of tailings from a catchment pond. Federal legislation requires Environment Canada to be notified of such leaks within 24 hours.

“The biggest learning from this is that the province has oversight and control over what information the federal government is receiving,” said Mandy Olsgard, a toxicologist who has worked on regulatory issues for the Alberta Energy Regulator and Indigenous groups.

Ottawa joins in the review panels that assess projects then mostly back away, Olsgard said. 

“They just hand it off to the province.”

And then the province hands it off to a regulator that many consider too close to the industry it’s supposed to oversee. 

“This regulator has always thought of its relationship being bilateral, between itself and industry,” said Nigel Bankes, a retired professor of resource law at the University of Calgary. “Never triangular, never a three-legged stool involving the public.

“For me, this (Kearl release) just confirmed all of that.”

That attitude is pervasive in the provincial government, Bankes said. 

“It’s a general message of don’t rock the boat,” he said. “It permeates the department of energy and it permeates Alberta Environment.”

Gabrielle Lamontagne, an Environment and Climate Change Canada spokesperson, said in an email the department is still figuring out what information Imperial reported to Alberta EDGE, in order to determine if the release met the triggers that would require the report to be forwarded to ECCC.

EDGE, which stands for Environmental and Dangerous Goods Emergencies, manages transportation of dangerous goods emergency calls in Alberta and assesses the severity of dangerous goods incidents. Its website says it “communicates openly with other regulatory agencies, such as the Alberta Energy Regulator (AER), in the event of an emergency or safety-related incident.”

A survey conducted in 2021 for Alberta Environment found more than 85 per cent of Albertans had little confidence in the regulator’s ability to govern industry, in that case coal. The survey also reported Albertans found the agency reluctant to release information and was not very transparent. 

Both federal Environment Minister Steven Guilbeault and his Alberta counterpart Sonya Savage have acknowledged things need to change.

“We need to take a step back and say ‘What are the processes? Were they followed? And do we need to enhance them?'” Savage said this week. “We’re committed to taking the step to enhancing all of those processes.”

“We need to find better mechanisms,” said Guilbeault.

But Marlin Schmidt, the Alberta New Democrat’s environment critic, is skeptical.

He said the province and the regulator have already refused to tell him the scope and timeline for the investigation of the leak. Savage wouldn’t commit to making the results of the investigation public, Schmidt said, nor would she promise to release results from an internal investigation into whether the regulator followed notification rules. 

“There’s no investigation into what process led to the failure, nor any commitment to improving,” he said. “We’re just shrugging our shoulders and hoping next time things work out better.”

The Kearl situation shows it can be a mistake for the federal government to “harmonize” regulations with the provinces and delegate oversight to them, Olszynski said.

“Given the kind of politics in this province, we could have seen that coming,” he said. “We should have known that these folks aren’t talking very well together, so you might want to rethink these arrangements that depend on them talking together.”

Olszynski said oilsands operators should now be required to report spills or any other unscheduled releases directly to the federal government.

“I think it is time for Environment Canada to take a much more proactive role in tailings management,” he said. 

The Kearl situation has made one thing clear, said Olsgard.

“It’s made it obvious to the public that there are not good processes between the provinces and the feds.”

This report by The Canadian Press was first published March 12, 2023.

Bob Weber, The Canadian Press


Keep it Factual
Add CityNews Toronto as a trusted source on Google to see more local stories from us.

Top Stories

Weight-loss drugs shaping up to be a boon for grocers' pharmacy units

While discount stores have been a bright spot recently for major grocery chains, other units within their empires have been quietly seeing a sales boom: their pharmacies. And it's largely coming from rising sales of weight-loss drugs. The popularity of Ozempic and other GLP-1 drugs, traditionally used to manage Type 2 diabetes, has exploded in recent years thanks to their weight-loss side effects. And as cheaper, generic versions become more widely available, uptake is only expected to rise further. Semaglutides, or GLP-1s as they're sometimes called, are the active ingredient in drugs like Ozempic. For grocers that have pharmacy units, signs of that growth are already noticeable in their financial reports. Loblaw Cos. Ltd., which owns Shoppers Drug Mart and Pharmaprix, reported a roughly 40 per cent surge in GLP-1 sales in each of its last two quarters. "We are beginning to see the impact of GLP-1 drugs going generic. It's still very early, but the initial indications are encouraging," Per Bank, chief executive of Loblaw, told analysts on an earnings call in July. Loblaw executives are projecting double-digit growth for GLP-1 sales in 2027. Metro Inc.'s outgoing chief executive, Eric La Flèche, struck a similar note during its earnings call last month. Metro owns Jean Coutu pharmacies. "Demand fundamentals remain strong with early evidence of increased patient adoption and higher prescription volumes," he said. Loblaw reported its drug retail same-store sales grew 4.6 per cent in its latest quarter, while Metro's pharmacy same-store sales were up 4.8 per cent. Both outpaced same-store sales metrics for food. The gains were driven by the prescriptions category. Even though generic versions of the drug mean lower prices, the growth in volume is still a net positive. "As generic supply continues to build, we expect ongoing expansion of the GLP-1 category to drive low-teens volume and contribution growth," La Flèche told analysts. That's "indicating that higher volumes should more than offset a meaningful portion of the price pressure from generalization," Veritas analyst Kathleen Wong said in a note about Metro's quarterly results in August. "The resulting price deflation is therefore likely to pressure pharmacy same-store sales measured in dollars, but Metro’s early experience suggests that increased accessibility and prescription volumes can offset part of that pressure at the contribution level." Health Canada has so far approved three generic semaglutide products, and is continuing to review more — making the country the first among G7 nations to do so. These used to be called the drug of the rich, said Amar Singh, senior director and head of Canadian retail insights at Kantar. "This drug was expensive, and now, with the generics coming out, this is increasing penetration as the cost has come down and more people can afford it," he said in an interview. Half of the respondents in a Leger poll from March said insurance coverage or a lower-cost generic would increase their likelihood of using a GLP-1. More than half cited weight loss as their primary reason for taking the drug. At that time, eight per cent — or three million Canadians — were on prescription GLP-1s, the survey suggested. With generics increasingly available in the market, Singh said he expects uptake to rise to about 20 per cent over the next year or two. That surge comes as Loblaw and Metro are expanding their pharmacy networks. Loblaw expects to have opened about 200 stores over the last three years, and roughly half are pharmacies, Wong said. Meanwhile, Empire acquired nine Morelli’s pharmacies in Ontario last month that are already situated within some Longo’s grocery stores. Jo-Ann McArthur, president of Nourish Food Marketing, said the increasing popularity of weight-loss drugs could be an opportunity for grocers to tailor customer experiences, especially as attitudes toward food change among weight-loss drug users. For instance, she said grocers could suggest GLP-1-friendly foods and offer meal planning through their loyalty apps, offer health-care insights for those on and off drugs, streamline store shelf labelling and market items that are weight-loss drug friendly. Late last year, Loblaw launched an online weight-management program for people to connect with health care practitioners and see if they qualify for the drugs. "Where they make more money (is) by providing more services and more advice and just making it easier for the consumer to just stay loyal," she said. And it's not just about keeping GLP-1 users within the same ecosystem. "People who are on these drugs often are controlling the whole family's shopping and meal prep," she said. "If one person in a family is on a diet, the whole family is on a diet." This report by The Canadian Press was first published Sept. 13, 2026.

2h ago

Top Stories

Weight-loss drugs shaping up to be a boon for grocers' pharmacy units

While discount stores have been a bright spot recently for major grocery chains, other units within their empires have been quietly seeing a sales boom: their pharmacies. And it's largely coming from rising sales of weight-loss drugs. The popularity of Ozempic and other GLP-1 drugs, traditionally used to manage Type 2 diabetes, has exploded in recent years thanks to their weight-loss side effects. And as cheaper, generic versions become more widely available, uptake is only expected to rise further. Semaglutides, or GLP-1s as they're sometimes called, are the active ingredient in drugs like Ozempic. For grocers that have pharmacy units, signs of that growth are already noticeable in their financial reports. Loblaw Cos. Ltd., which owns Shoppers Drug Mart and Pharmaprix, reported a roughly 40 per cent surge in GLP-1 sales in each of its last two quarters. "We are beginning to see the impact of GLP-1 drugs going generic. It's still very early, but the initial indications are encouraging," Per Bank, chief executive of Loblaw, told analysts on an earnings call in July. Loblaw executives are projecting double-digit growth for GLP-1 sales in 2027. Metro Inc.'s outgoing chief executive, Eric La Flèche, struck a similar note during its earnings call last month. Metro owns Jean Coutu pharmacies. "Demand fundamentals remain strong with early evidence of increased patient adoption and higher prescription volumes," he said. Loblaw reported its drug retail same-store sales grew 4.6 per cent in its latest quarter, while Metro's pharmacy same-store sales were up 4.8 per cent. Both outpaced same-store sales metrics for food. The gains were driven by the prescriptions category. Even though generic versions of the drug mean lower prices, the growth in volume is still a net positive. "As generic supply continues to build, we expect ongoing expansion of the GLP-1 category to drive low-teens volume and contribution growth," La Flèche told analysts. That's "indicating that higher volumes should more than offset a meaningful portion of the price pressure from generalization," Veritas analyst Kathleen Wong said in a note about Metro's quarterly results in August. "The resulting price deflation is therefore likely to pressure pharmacy same-store sales measured in dollars, but Metro’s early experience suggests that increased accessibility and prescription volumes can offset part of that pressure at the contribution level." Health Canada has so far approved three generic semaglutide products, and is continuing to review more — making the country the first among G7 nations to do so. These used to be called the drug of the rich, said Amar Singh, senior director and head of Canadian retail insights at Kantar. "This drug was expensive, and now, with the generics coming out, this is increasing penetration as the cost has come down and more people can afford it," he said in an interview. Half of the respondents in a Leger poll from March said insurance coverage or a lower-cost generic would increase their likelihood of using a GLP-1. More than half cited weight loss as their primary reason for taking the drug. At that time, eight per cent — or three million Canadians — were on prescription GLP-1s, the survey suggested. With generics increasingly available in the market, Singh said he expects uptake to rise to about 20 per cent over the next year or two. That surge comes as Loblaw and Metro are expanding their pharmacy networks. Loblaw expects to have opened about 200 stores over the last three years, and roughly half are pharmacies, Wong said. Meanwhile, Empire acquired nine Morelli’s pharmacies in Ontario last month that are already situated within some Longo’s grocery stores. Jo-Ann McArthur, president of Nourish Food Marketing, said the increasing popularity of weight-loss drugs could be an opportunity for grocers to tailor customer experiences, especially as attitudes toward food change among weight-loss drug users. For instance, she said grocers could suggest GLP-1-friendly foods and offer meal planning through their loyalty apps, offer health-care insights for those on and off drugs, streamline store shelf labelling and market items that are weight-loss drug friendly. Late last year, Loblaw launched an online weight-management program for people to connect with health care practitioners and see if they qualify for the drugs. "Where they make more money (is) by providing more services and more advice and just making it easier for the consumer to just stay loyal," she said. And it's not just about keeping GLP-1 users within the same ecosystem. "People who are on these drugs often are controlling the whole family's shopping and meal prep," she said. "If one person in a family is on a diet, the whole family is on a diet." This report by The Canadian Press was first published Sept. 13, 2026.

2h ago

Most Watched Today