How effective are booster shots against Omicron? They’re key but still much to learn

The new Omicron variant took only a few weeks to live up to dire predictions about how hugely contagious it is but scientists don’t yet know if it causes more severe disease even as the world faces exploding cases just before Christmas.

“Everything is riskier now because Omicron is so much more contagious,” said Dr. S. Wesley Long, who directs the testing lab at Houston Methodist Hospital — and over the past week has cancelled numerous plans to avoid exposure.

Omicron now is the dominant variant in the U.S., federal health officials said Monday, accounting for about three-quarters of new infections last week. In Canada — specifically in Ontario — the latest modelling suggests that the increased transmissibility of the Omicron variant could put additional strain on provincial hospital capacity, making it critical to slow the spread as the Ford government dramatically increases vaccine capacity and expands eligibility for booster doses.

The speed that it’s outpacing the also very contagious Delta variant is astonishing public health officials. In three weeks, Omicron now makes up 80 per cent of new symptomatic cases diagnosed by Houston Methodist’s testing sites. It took the Delta variant three months to reach that level, Long said.

BREAKING: CDC estimates 73% of new coronavirus cases in the U.S. are caused by the Omicron variant, up from 3% last week

— BNO News (@BNOFeed) December 20, 2021

The mutant’s ability to spread faster and evade immunity came at a bad time — right as travel increased and many people let down their guard. But what the Omicron wave will mean for the world is still unclear because so many questions remain unanswered.

Here’s the latest on what’s known and what’s still to learn about Omicron.

How much protection do vaccines offer?

Vaccines in the U.S. and around the world do not offer as much protection against Omicron as they have against previous versions of the coronavirus. However, vaccines still help — a lot. Lab tests show while two doses may not be strong enough to prevent infection, a booster shot of either the Pfizer or Moderna vaccine produces virus-fighting antibodies capable of tackling Omicron.

Antibody levels naturally drop over time, and a booster revved them back up again, by 25 times for Pfizer’s extra shot and 37 times for Moderna’s. No one knows exactly what level is high enough — or how long it will be before antibody levels begin dropping again.

After a booster, the protection against an Omicron infection still appears about 20 per cent less than protection against the Delta variant, said Dr. Egon Ozer of Northwestern University.

But if the virus gets past that first line of defense, the vaccinated have additional layers of protection.

“The vaccines are going to protect you against severe disease, hospitalization and death,” said Houston Methodist’s Long.

“And that’s really the most important thing.”

Those extra defenses include T cells that mobilize to beat back the virus, plus memory cells that, once reactivated, race to make more and stronger antibodies.

What about natural immunity?

Prior infection doesn’t seem to offer much protection against an Omicron infection although, like with vaccination, it may reduce the chances of severe illness.

In South Africa, where Omicron already has spread widely, scientists reported a jump in reinfections that they hadn’t seen when two previous mutants, including delta, moved through the country.

In Britain, a report from the Imperial College of London on Friday found the risk of reinfection from Omicron was five times higher compared to the earlier Delta variant.

Health experts say anyone who’s survived a bout of COVID-19 still should get vaccinated because the combination generally offers stronger protection.

December, 2021: There are 62 confirmed cases of the Omicron variant in Ontario, and the province’s expert science advisory group estimates that 11 per cent of cases are caused by the new variant. 

Why does Omicron spread so fast?

Scientists are trying to decode the dozens of mutations that Omicron carries to figure out what else is going on. Researchers in Hong Kong recently reported hints that Omicron may multiply more quickly in the airway than Delta did, although not as efficiently deep in the lungs.

What scientists can’t measure is human behavior: Many places were relaxing restrictions, winter forced gatherings indoors and travel has jumped right as Omicron began spreading.

Is Omicron causing milder illness?

It’s still too early to know — especially given that if the vaccinated get a breakthrough infection, it should be milder than if omicron attacks the unvaccinated.

Early reports from South Africa suggested milder illness but doctors were unsure whether that’s because the population is fairly young — or that many retained some protection from a recent Delta infection.

And that British study found no evidence that Omicron has been milder than Delta in Britain, even with young adults — who would be expected to have milder illness — having higher rates of infection with Omicron.

“There’s a hint, and I think many of us are hopeful, that omicron will be less severe. But I don’t think we can bet the farm on that. We’re still talking about SARS CoV-2, a virus that has killed millions of people,” said Dr. Jacob Lemieux, who monitors variants for a research collaboration led by Harvard Medical School.

Who is most at risk?

Based on the behaviour of other variants, “if you’re older, if you have underlying conditions, if you’re obese, you’re more likely to have severe disease. I don’t think it’s going to be any different” than other variants, said Dr. Carlos del Rio of Emory University.

But even if you don’t get very sick, an Omicron infection could certainly ruin the holidays. Experts agree that in addition to getting vaccinated and boosted, it’s wise to get back to the basics of protection: Wear masks indoors, avoid crowds and keep your distance.